Sandwich Maker Reviews: 5 Best Toasters for Homemade Toasties

Short on time, or like getting straight to the point? The outcome we reached in our search for the best sandwich maker is the Breville VST041 Deep Fill Sandwich Toaster which we see as the best buy!

If you’ve eaten a toastie before, then you know what a little slice of heaven they can be. And if you haven’t, then your in for a treat! The best toastie makers are usually quick, efficient and leave as little mess as possible.

Unfortunately, im sure we have all had ones where the excess cheese leaks over the side or the toastie doesn’t cook properly and you end up with a soggy sandwich. Well not today, below were going to show you what a proper toastie maker is!

In this article, were going to review the following sandwich makers:

There are certain aspects of a sandwich maker that are important to remember before buying, especially when you consider that their primary goal is to save you time and provide excellent quality meals.

What To Look For In A Great Sandwich Maker

Nowadays a toastie maker can be more than just a simple one dimensional product, some have been impressively created as multi functional where they can grill vegetables, cook meat, press a panini and even make you waffles!

Size & Design

A sandwich toaster is all about quality and accessibility, however there are some stylish models out there to match the decor of your kitchen. Brands such as George Foreman & Von Shef are popular for their quality whilst not sticking out like a saw thumb on the kitchen worktop.

Purchasing a small to medium sized sandwich press is usually the wiser idea as these are more compatible and fit easier into kitchen cupboards or drawers.

How Much Should I Spend?

As many sandwich toaster reviews show, prices for these products can range drastically from less than the cost of breakfast, right up to over 3 figures for an all singing and dancing one. However, we think that is on the steep side to say the least!

Out of the numerous models we tried and tested, we managed to whittle it down to 5 with even our most expensive maker coming in at an affordable cost which we think is reasonable considering the versatility & durability it provides.

Are They Easy To Clean?

It’s vitally important that you clean the product after use because if it’s left, you will have to scrape crusty old bits of cheese off the inside, making for quite an unpleasant experience. A simple damp cloth will do the trick and just gently glide around the edges and across the plates.

If you really don’t want to have to face cleaning them, check to see if your plates are removable and dishwasher friendly.

What Features Are A Must?

There are a few fundamental things that your toasted sandwich maker should do. These include sealing the sandwich well so that it’s tightly compressed, the non stick surface should be efficient and the toastie should have a light brown coating across it evenly.

Product Reviews & Buyers Guide

We’ve researched a number of different models to determine the best sandwich maker, and we’ve based our results on the best quality, price, size & versatility that it offers.

1. Best Deep Filled Sandwich Grill: Breville VST041 Deep Fill Sandwich

The Breville machine is difficult to beat based on the feedback we’ve had. The toaster takes roughly 5 minutes to heat up to it’s required temperature and can cook up to 2 toasted sandwiches at a time.

They are deep filled allowing for plenty of your favourite filling, whilst the plates are easily removed and dishwasher friendly.


  • 68% of people gave it 5 stars out 2,248 reviews
  • Compact making it easy to store away
  • Stylish stainless silver case
  • Sturdy and quality build
  • Excellent value according to customers


  • Main part of the machine can be difficult to clean
  • Some customer complaints of leakage

>> Check Price At Amazon <<

2. Best 3 in 1 Sandwich Maker: 750W Kitchen Toaster By Crystals

The 750W Kitchen 3 in 1 Toaster is ideal for making a variety of meals with one machine. It’s versatility is incredible and it can act as a sandwich toaster, waffle maker or panini griller, you decide!

It comes with non sticking coating plates (which will make cleaning it afterwards that much easier) and a thermo insulated handle.

The size of this appliance is approximately 235 x 240 x 100mm with a voltage of 220- 240V. This makes it easily packable within a kitchen cupboard and doesn’t have to sit permanently on the worktop.


  • Light & compatible for putting away
  • Extremely versatile for the price
  • Grill & Waffle plates are removable to clean
  • Includes a concealed connection spring
  • A stylish model


  • Some customers found it difficult to clean
  • May be better models

>> Check Price At Amazon <<

3. Best Toaster With Removal Plates: VonShef 2 in 1 Waffle Maker & Sandwich Toaster

This model is simple to use and even easier to clean with it’s removable plates that slide out without any mess whatsoever. You can then simply just wipe them down with a wet cloth and prevent any food from becoming hard on the plates.

It has a simple ready to use light, once that turns off, it indicates that the appliance has heated up to its optimal temperature.

If there are 4 of you that want something to eat, no problem! With 4 large slice plates you can make your guests a yummy treat in no time without anyone having to wait around.


  • Ideal for family parties
  • Includes free delivery
  • Manufacturer 2 year warranty included
  • Can place the plates in the dishwasher
  • Compact making easy for storage


  • Customers complained about lack of instructions
  • Can take a bit longer to cook than other models

>> Check Price At Amazon <<

4. Best Single Sandwich Toaster: Judge Mini Sandwich Maker

Due to it only being a single sandwich maker, it makes hardly any mess and is easy to clean.

It has a non stick toasting plate, with a seal and cut action making it easy to use for all ages of adults. Due to it’s small frame, it saves plenty of space and stands upright making it easy for storage.

Over 70% of customers gave this maker 5 stars which ceratinaly tells you that the product your buying is well worth it’s price tag.


  • Very cheap for the quality of product
  • Easy to wipe down with a damp cloth
  • Quick due to only being a single
  • Includes an indicator light for when to cook


  • Plates are not removable
  • Customers mentioned unclear instructions

>> Check Price At Amazon <<

5. Best Large 4 Slice Toastie Machine: Tower T27021 4-Slice Deep Fill Sandwich Maker

Considered by many as the best sandwich toaster, this top quality model can make up to 4 scrumptious deep filled toasted sandwiches in minutes. It is a powerful 1800W allowing it to grill quickly and efficiently.

74% out of 265 customer reviews have rated this product with 5 stars highlighting its quality and durability.

The large plates mean that there’s no excess cheese or other foods overflowing over the edges and causing a mess.


  • Both heat up time and cooking time are very quick
  • Plates retain their non stick nature even after wear & tear according to customers.
  • Excellent value for money according to reviews
  • Use little to no oil making it a healthier snack
  • Automatic temperature control


  • Some customers stated they couldn’t find bread big enough to fill the plates
  • A large product so difficult to put away in storage

>> Check Price At Amazon <<

To Wrap It Up, My Personal Recommendation

As with any product, it all depends on your lifestyle and what you hope to get out of it. We believe the Breville Deep Fill Sandwich is the best buy.

With over 2000 reviews on this product, it has been well tested and continuously provides excellent toasties, no one ever complains about the quality of the food. It has a mid tier price with people stating they’ve had there’s for years without any problems at all.

Whichever you choose to buy, know that we’ve done the research for you, so you can buy with confidence knowing your getting one of the best models on the market.

John Devlin

Hello Hello, thanks for stopping by, John here and am the guy behind Easier House. Hopefully by now you’ve had a chance to look around the site and i am really hoping your enjoying it thus far! If like me you a bit fanatical about your house then you’ll find some quality bits and pieces on this site.
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.